• Curaçao Chronicle
  • (599-9) 523-4857

The warning light is not the problem

Opinion, Op-Ed, | By Ashton Lopez November 19, 2026

 

On International Men’s Day, it is worth asking what we teach boys about strength, and what it costs them to believe it.

When a warning light appears on a car dashboard, nobody proves their toughness by covering it with tape. We pay attention because ignoring the signal could make the damage worse. Yet when a boy cries, or a man admits that he is afraid, we sometimes treat the signal itself as the problem.

The lesson is rarely written down. It may come when a child is told to stop crying after a fall, when a father hides his worries because everyone depends on him, or when a young man working abroad tells his family he is fine because they have already sacrificed so much. For others, silence grows from grief, money problems, public expectations or the fear that a private conversation will travel through a small community. These are different lives, not one diagnosis. But the message can sound remarkably similar: carry it yourself.

It is tempting to call this simply the way men are. The evidence is more complicated. Psychologists Tara Chaplin and Amelia Aldao reviewed 166 studies involving 21,709 children. On average, differences between boys and girls in emotional expression were small, and they varied with age, the type of emotion and the social setting. The study does not prove that every difference is learned. It does challenge the easy assumption that boys arrive in the world with little emotional life.

A separate study of self-reported crying across 37 countries found substantial differences between men and women, as well as between countries. Self-reports cannot tell us precisely how much comes from biology, social expectations or what people are willing to admit. They do remind us that the rules around emotion are shaped by context, not fixed equally everywhere.

History offers another warning against confusing a custom with human nature. Historian Thomas Dixon has shown that Britain’s celebrated “stiff upper lip” was not an eternal national characteristic. It became especially influential in the Victorian and imperial period. What later generations remember as tradition was itself a change in what men were expected to show.

The same tension is visible in sport. In 2018, basketball player Kevin Love wrote publicly about a panic attack and the expectation that men should handle their feelings alone. In the Dutch documentary Echte Mannen Huilen Niet, released in March 2026, professional footballers speak about grief, panic and the pressure to appear unbreakable. Their experiences do not speak for every man. They do show that success, status and physical strength do not remove the need for support.

The consequences deserve more than a slogan. A meta-analysis led by psychologist Y. Joel Wong combined 78 samples involving 19,453 participants. Stronger adherence to some traditional masculine norms, particularly extreme self-reliance, was associated with less favorable mental-health outcomes and more negative attitudes toward seeking psychological help. These findings do not tell us the size of that relationship for Caribbean men, and an association is not proof that a belief caused an illness.

The Caribbean nonetheless has reasons to take the issue seriously. In its 2023 report on masculinities and men’s health in the region, the Pan American Health Organization described a heavier burden of preventable illness and death among men, including harm from violence and injuries, and lower engagement with preventive care. These outcomes have many causes: work and income, health services, social circumstances, behavior and biology. Silence cannot explain them all. But a culture that makes seeking help feel shameful can make an already difficult situation harder.

Strength is not the same as silence

There is something worth preserving in the ideals passed from one generation to the next: showing up for family, keeping promises, helping a neighbor and remaining steady in a crisis. The mistake is to assume that these qualities require emotional distance. Research with Mexican American men by G. Miguel Arciniega and colleagues distinguished a controlling version of machismo from caballerismo, associated with emotional connection and constructive problem-solving. That research should not be treated as a description of every Caribbean household. Its useful lesson is narrower: the values often grouped under “being a man” need not lead to the same behavior.

Consider what happens when we move beyond telling men to “open up.” A boy needs to know that his feelings will not become a joke at home or in the changing room. A father may need someone who can listen without immediately questioning his ability to provide. A worker who cannot afford time off needs access to care that fits the reality of his working day. In a close-knit community, confidentiality may matter as much as encouragement. Advice has limited value if the conditions for using it are missing.

Families, coaches, employers and health services each have a part to play. Adults can model honest language without burdening children with adult problems. Coaches can respond to distress without humiliation. Employers can make support genuinely confidential, and health providers can explain how to access it before a crisis. These are small changes in ordinary settings, but they test whether our public encouragement is matched by private behavior.

There is also a practical place to begin today. Think of someone who has become unusually quiet, irritable or distant. Rather than demanding an explanation, name what you have noticed: “You seem to be carrying a lot lately. I’m here if you want to talk, or we can just take a walk.” Listen without rushing to fix it. If there is concern about immediate safety or suicide, ask directly, take the answer seriously and involve professional or emergency support. A conversation matters; it is not a substitute for care when care is needed.

We cannot choose every expectation we inherited. We can decide which ones we repeat. The question for International Men’s Day is not whether boys should be strong. It is whether we have taught them that strength means ignoring every warning light, even when someone is willing to help.

Ashton Lopez is the author of The Power of the Unknown, scheduled for publication on 10 December 2026.  •  weflourish.global/ashtonlopez

Where to find support

Aruba: 131 (ages 8–24; daily 14:00–18:00).

Curaçao: 918 (up to 25; Mon–Fri 10:00–18:00; Sat 12:00–18:00).

Sint Maarten: Mental Health Foundation crisis: +1 721 585-5556.

Netherlands: 113 Zelfmoordpreventie: 0800-0113 (24/7).

+