• Curaçao Chronicle
  • (599-9) 523-4857

PAR Demands Full Disclosure of Consultancy Costs for Justice Ministry Reorganizations Between 2022 and 2026

Local, Politics, | By Correspondent November 20, 2026

 

WILLEMSTAD – PAR Member of Parliament Shaheen Elhage is demanding a detailed financial account of consultancy and advisory expenditures associated with reorganizations at several institutions under Curaçao's Ministry of Justice.

In parliamentary questions submitted on November 10, 2026, Elhage asked Justice Minister Shalten Hato to disclose how much public money was spent between 2022 and 2026 on assignments involving the Government Accountants Bureau (SOAB) and other consultancy organizations.

The request covers restructuring activities at the Curaçao Detention and Correction Center (SDKK), the Judicial Youth Institution Curaçao (JJIC), NCB-INTERPOL Curaçao, the Curaçao Fire Department, and parts of the former National Security Service.

Elhage wants to determine whether the government received measurable results from the consultancy work and whether adequate controls were in place to prevent unnecessary or overlapping expenditures.

Detailed Breakdown of Spending Requested

The parliamentarian is asking for a complete financial breakdown of SOAB assignments related to organizational restructuring, job evaluations, staffing plans, and job classification manuals.

He wants expenditures specified by institution and year, including original budgets and actual spending.

The request also extends to other consultancy firms that may have participated in the restructuring processes.

Elhage specifically mentioned Deloitte Caribbean and Balance Consultancy, asking the government to clarify whether these organizations were contracted, what assignments they received, and how much they were paid.

He also wants to know how the ministry ensured that different organizations were not paid to perform the same work.

The parliamentary letter does not specify the total amount spent or allege that duplicate payments have been established.

Instead, Elhage is requesting the financial records needed to determine whether public funds were managed efficiently.

Questions About Value for Money

Elhage believes consultancy spending must be evaluated against actual improvements in government services.

He is asking the minister to identify measurable results achieved through the reorganizations.

These include improvements in operational efficiency, staffing capacity, service quality, and expenditure reduction.

He also wants the government to provide documentation supporting any reported improvements.

According to the parliamentarian, the preparation of reports and organizational plans should not be treated as evidence of successful restructuring unless the recommendations have been implemented and have produced demonstrable benefits.

Consultancy Independence Under Scrutiny

Another issue concerns SOAB's dual role in providing organizational support and carrying out government auditing activities.

Elhage wants to know how the Ministry of Justice protects SOAB's independence when the organization provides advice or assistance on projects that it might subsequently be asked to evaluate.

He is requesting information about the criteria used to award assignments to SOAB and whether those assignments formed part of its regular oversight responsibilities or were separate consultancy projects.

The questions reflect concerns about the need for clear distinctions between advisory responsibilities and independent oversight.

Contracts, Invoices and Reports Requested

Elhage has formally requested that the Justice Minister provide Parliament with the underlying documentation associated with the restructuring programs.

The requested records include assignment letters, cost estimates, invoices, payment summaries, final reports, and implementation plans.

He also wants copies of relevant consultancy recommendations and information about which recommendations have been approved or implemented.

Where documents contain personal or confidential information, Elhage suggested that the ministry consider providing redacted versions or submitting them confidentially under applicable rules.

If documents do not exist or are unavailable, he wants the government to state that clearly and explain why.

Parliament Wants Accountability for Results

Elhage is also calling for a comprehensive report covering the financial costs, government decisions, results, unresolved issues, and implementation schedules associated with the reorganizations.

He argues that Parliament's oversight responsibility requires access to more than consultancy reports and policy intentions.

Lawmakers must be able to determine what the government approved, what was actually implemented, how much was spent, and what improvements the public received.

The parliamentarian has requested a response within two months, referring to the protocol governing parliamentary questions between the government and Parliament.

If the minister cannot meet that deadline, Elhage expects written notification explaining the reasons and indicating when the requested information will be provided.

The requested disclosure could give Parliament a clearer picture of the costs and effectiveness of restructuring efforts across Curaçao's justice institutions.

+