NEW YORK – Former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores, are seeking to prevent their federal criminal case in the United States from proceeding to trial, arguing that they are protected by sovereign immunity. Their legal challenge is expected to take center stage during a hearing scheduled for December 17, 2026, before U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres in Manhattan.
The upcoming hearing could become an important turning point in the proceedings, as the court considers whether the criminal charges should move forward and whether certain allegations belong in a different federal judicial district.
Maduro and Flores face federal charges involving narcoterrorism, cocaine importation, firearms offenses, and conspiracy to commit torture. Both defendants retain the presumption of innocence, and the allegations must be proven in court.
New Judge Takes Over High-Profile Case
The proceedings are now being overseen by Judge Analisa Torres of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
Torres replaced Judge Alvin Hellerstein, who died on October 28, 2026, at the age of 92.
After taking responsibility for the case, Torres ordered that previously established court orders and procedural deadlines remain in effect unless subsequently modified.
The change in judicial leadership comes at a critical stage, with defense attorneys seeking to resolve several legal objections before the case reaches trial.
The next hearing is expected to focus primarily on those preliminary challenges rather than on determining whether Maduro and Flores committed the alleged crimes.
Maduro Claims Immunity From U.S. Prosecution
One of the central arguments advanced by Maduro's defense is that he should be protected from criminal prosecution in the United States because of his claimed status as a head of state.
His attorneys contend that sovereign immunity prevents American courts from exercising criminal jurisdiction over him.
Flores has also asserted an immunity claim.
Federal prosecutors oppose the defense's position. Among their arguments, they maintain that the Venezuelan government has not formally requested such protection on behalf of the couple.
The disagreement raises legal questions about the scope of immunity, the circumstances under which it may apply, and whether it prevents the prosecution from proceeding.
Judge Torres will be responsible for evaluating the competing arguments under the applicable law.
The defense's assertion of immunity does not automatically terminate the prosecution, just as the government's opposition does not establish that the immunity claims are invalid.
A judicial determination will be required.
Dispute Over Torture Conspiracy Charge
A separate legal disagreement concerns a conspiracy-to-commit-torture charge added to the federal case in October.
Defense attorneys argue that this allegation should be handled in the Eastern District of New York, which includes Brooklyn, rather than the Southern District of New York in Manhattan.
They have challenged the procedural basis used by prosecutors to justify bringing the charge in Manhattan.
The objection concerns the appropriate location for prosecuting the allegation, a legal issue commonly referred to as venue.
It does not, by itself, determine whether the underlying accusation is true or false.
The defense has requested that the court address the immunity arguments before resolving the venue dispute.
Depending on the judge's findings, the legal challenges could affect how certain charges are handled as the case moves toward trial.
Serious Federal Charges Remain Contested
The federal indictment includes allegations involving narcoterrorism, cocaine trafficking, firearms, and conspiracy to commit torture.
Prosecutors allege that American citizens were among the victims of torture connected to the case.
These accusations form part of the government's criminal case and remain subject to judicial scrutiny.
The prosecution must establish the necessary elements of each offense under the applicable burden of proof.
Maduro and Flores are entitled to challenge the evidence, dispute the government's legal arguments, and exercise their rights under the American judicial system.
The pending motions focus on whether the prosecution may proceed under the existing legal framework, rather than on a final determination of guilt.
What Could Happen on December 17?
The December 17 hearing is expected to involve legal arguments from federal prosecutors and defense attorneys concerning immunity and other procedural objections.
Judge Torres could issue rulings on some of the pending motions during the hearing or reserve her decisions until she has completed a further review of the legal submissions.
Several outcomes are therefore possible, including the continuation of proceedings while the court considers unresolved questions.
The scheduling of the hearing does not mean that Maduro or Flores will necessarily be released, that charges will be dismissed, or that a final judgment will be delivered that day.
Any such outcome would depend on the court's formal decisions.
Trial Scheduled for June 2027
The criminal trial is currently scheduled to begin on June 14, 2027, although that date remains subject to the outcome of pending motions and possible changes to the court's calendar.
The December hearing could help determine which charges remain before the court and what procedural conditions will apply as the case approaches trial.
For Venezuela and the wider Caribbean region, the proceedings continue to attract attention because of their political and legal significance.
The case also raises broader questions about the prosecution of former or disputed national leaders in foreign courts, the limits of sovereign immunity, and the jurisdiction of the United States over alleged international crimes.
For now, the immediate focus remains on the legal arguments before Judge Torres.
Her decisions could shape the next phase of the prosecution and determine whether the case proceeds toward its scheduled June 2027 trial under the current indictment.