THE HAGUE – Curaçao, Aruba, and Sint Maarten will not automatically benefit from proposed Dutch legislation aimed at intercepting vessels sailing without valid nationality, despite confirmation that ships illegally using the Kingdom's flag have been detected in the Caribbean Sea.
The Dutch government has made clear that the three autonomous Caribbean countries must introduce their own legislation if they wish to establish comparable enforcement powers within their territorial waters.
The clarification was provided by Dutch Minister of Infrastructure and Water Management Vincent Karremans in responses to parliamentary questions about the Russian shadow fleet, published on November 16, 2026.
The Netherlands is preparing legislation that would allow authorities to inspect and detain stateless vessels and escort them to a port.
However, the proposed powers will not extend to the territorial waters of Curaçao, Aruba, or Sint Maarten.
Caribbean Countries Responsible for Their Own Legislation
According to the Dutch government, each autonomous Caribbean country within the Kingdom is responsible for deciding whether comparable legislation should be introduced.
This means Curaçao would have to consider its own legal framework if it wants to establish similar powers to detain ships operating without valid nationality.
The distinction is important because the Kingdom shares international responsibilities in certain areas, while the individual countries maintain their own legal and administrative systems.
The proposed Dutch legislation is primarily intended to address vessels involved in circumventing international sanctions against Russia, particularly those transporting Russian oil.
The Netherlands wants stronger legal instruments to intervene when ships operate without valid nationality.
However, the government has decided not to extend those new powers automatically to the Caribbean countries.
Bonaire, Sint Eustatius, and Saba Also Excluded
The proposed enforcement powers will also not apply in the territorial waters of Bonaire, Sint Eustatius, and Saba.
Although these three islands are special municipalities of the Netherlands, the Dutch government has decided not to introduce the additional powers in their territorial waters.
The Dutch Human Environment and Transport Inspectorate (ILT) will therefore not receive additional enforcement responsibilities in these waters under the proposed legislation.
One of the government's concerns involves the practical challenges associated with detaining large commercial vessels in the Caribbean.
According to the parliamentary responses, the islands have limited port and inspection capacity.
Holding a large vessel for an extended period could create logistical and operational difficulties, particularly where suitable port facilities and inspection resources are limited.
These considerations have influenced the government's decision not to extend the proposed enforcement system to the Caribbean territories.
Caribbean Coast Guard Retains Existing Powers
The absence of the new Dutch powers does not mean that authorities are unable to intervene against criminal activities at sea.
The Dutch government emphasized that the Caribbean Coast Guard can continue carrying out operations against suspected criminal activities under the authority of the competent judicial authorities.
Military personnel may also provide support when required.
However, these existing arrangements are separate from the additional powers being proposed in the Netherlands specifically for vessels without valid nationality.
The distinction means that enforcement against maritime crime can continue, but the Caribbean territories will not automatically receive the new legal instruments being developed to address stateless vessels.
Limited Effectiveness Against Russian Shadow Fleet
The Dutch government also acknowledged that the proposed legislation would address only part of the broader problem involving Russia's shadow fleet.
Of the 674 vessels on the European sanctions list cited in the parliamentary response, approximately 109 operate without valid nationality.
The remaining 84 percent sail under valid foreign flags.
As a result, the proposed powers to detain stateless vessels would not apply to most ships on the sanctions list solely because of their registration status.
The Netherlands is therefore pursuing additional measures through European sanctions and cooperation with other flag states.
For Curaçao, the development raises questions about whether existing maritime legislation and enforcement arrangements are sufficient to address vessels operating without valid nationality.
Dutch authorities have confirmed that some ships falsely using the Kingdom's flag have been observed in the Caribbean Sea, although they have not disclosed their precise locations.
No announcement has been made indicating whether the Curaçao government intends to introduce legislation comparable to the Dutch proposal.
For now, any decision to establish additional powers to detain stateless vessels in Curaçao's territorial waters would require action by the country's own authorities.