• Curaçao Chronicle
  • (599-9) 523-4857

Curaçao Court Rules Luxury Tourism Projects Can Serve Public Interest Despite Environmental Concerns

Local, | By Correspondent November 19, 2026

 

WILLEMSTAD – A landmark ruling involving a luxury resort expansion in Curaçao has clarified that privately operated tourism developments can qualify as projects serving the public interest, even when they involve activities affecting protected marine environments.

The Court of First Instance reached that conclusion in a November 18, 2026 judgment concerning Flamingo Ontwikkelingsmaatschappij B.V. (FOM), which is seeking to expand an existing luxury resort through a coastal land reclamation project.

Although the court ultimately overturned the project's coral removal exemption because of inadequate environmental research, it rejected the argument that a privately owned commercial development cannot qualify for an exemption based on the public interest.

The ruling provides important clarification about how Curaçao's environmental legislation applies to tourism investments and the government's responsibility to balance economic development against nature conservation.

Private Development Can Have Wider Economic Benefits

The case arose after neighboring property owners and Fundashon Pro Monumento (ProMo) challenged an exemption issued by the Minister of Health, Environment and Nature.

One of their central arguments was that the proposed resort expansion primarily served the commercial interests of a private company and therefore should not qualify for an exemption allowing activities that would otherwise be prohibited under Curaçao's Reef Management Ordinance.

The court disagreed.

It explained that the legislation allows exemptions for projects serving the public interest and that this provision is not restricted to government projects.

In reaching its conclusion, the court examined the legislative history of an amendment introduced in 1989.

That amendment specifically recognized that both private and public projects could serve broader societal interests.

The court noted that the legislative explanation even referred to the construction of a beach and pier associated with the expansion of the Avila Beach Hotel as an example.

According to the judges, the commercial nature of a project does not automatically exclude the possibility that it may also benefit society.

Government Defends Luxury Tourism Strategy

In defending the exemption, the government argued that the resort expansion would contribute to Curaçao's economic development by strengthening the luxury tourism sector.

The minister maintained that higher-end tourism could generate greater economic value than mass tourism because visitors in this segment generally spend more on accommodation, restaurants, services, and recreational activities.

The government also argued that luxury developments could create employment, generate tax revenue, and stimulate investment in related economic sectors.

Another consideration was land availability.

According to the minister, luxury resorts require relatively large spaces to provide privacy, natural surroundings, and lower-density accommodations.

The government maintained that FOM had limited room for further expansion on its existing property and that coastal reclamation would provide the additional space needed.

The court accepted that these socioeconomic and spatial considerations could legitimately form part of the government's public-interest assessment.

It found that the minister had sufficiently explained how the project could provide benefits extending beyond the commercial interests of its operator.

Environmental Protection Remains a Legal Requirement

Despite accepting the government's economic reasoning, the court emphasized that public-interest considerations do not eliminate the obligation to protect the marine environment.

The development involves reclaiming approximately 2,800 square meters of coastal land.

Plans discussed during the proceedings envision approximately ten additional accommodation units, each intended for a maximum of two guests, although the final building plans have not yet been approved.

The environmental studies presented to the government indicated that the coral reef in the project area had deteriorated considerably.

According to comparative research by EcoVision, coral coverage declined by approximately 63 percent between 2023 and 2025.

The court identified several pressures affecting the reef, including coral disease, elevated nutrient concentrations associated with a leaking sewage pipe near the eastern side of the resort, strong wave action, and turbid shallow water.

The government argued that the development could also contribute to environmental restoration through a coral relocation and compensation program.

FOM's proposed program includes the restoration and ecological improvement of at least 3,000 square meters of coral reef habitat over ten years.

The company initially committed XCG 50,000 annually to the program but subsequently increased that commitment to US$50,000 per year in August 2026.

The court did not reject the government's reliance on the reef's deteriorated condition or its consideration of the proposed restoration measures.

However, it found that the underlying research failed to establish adequately whether specially protected coral species were present within the full construction area.

Consequently, the environmental exemption could not remain in force.

A Broader Question for Curaçao's Tourism Development

The judgment highlights an important distinction in Curaçao's development policy.

A tourism investment may serve the public interest and generate economic benefits, but those benefits do not automatically justify activities that could harm internationally protected species.

The government must first establish the environmental facts and comply with all applicable legal safeguards.

For FOM, this means the proposed expansion remains dependent on a new environmental assessment and a fresh decision by the responsible minister.

The case also illustrates the legal complexity surrounding coastal development as Curaçao continues to expand its tourism industry.

The court's reasoning confirms that economic growth and environmental protection are not necessarily incompatible objectives. However, it makes equally clear that a government decision allowing development in sensitive marine areas must be based on sufficiently complete scientific evidence.

The minister must reconsider FOM's application within four months of the judgment being sent.

The outcome of that reassessment will determine whether the project can obtain the environmental authorization necessary to proceed.

The ruling may also have broader implications for future coastal tourism projects, particularly those involving land reclamation, coral relocation, and the interpretation of the public interest under Curaçao's environmental laws.

+