• Curaçao Chronicle
  • (599-9) 523-4857

Court Overturns Coral Removal Permit for Luxury Resort Expansion in Curaçao

Local, | By Correspondent November 19, 2026

 

WILLEMSTAD – The Court of First Instance of Curaçao has overturned an environmental exemption granted to Flamingo Ontwikkelingsmaatschappij B.V. (FOM) for a luxury resort expansion project, ruling that the government failed to conduct sufficiently thorough research into the presence of internationally protected coral species at the proposed development site.

In its judgment of November 18, 2026, the court ruled in favor of neighboring property owners and the environmental heritage organization Fundashon Pro Monumento (ProMo), who challenged the exemption issued by the Minister of Health, Environment and Nature (GMN).

The decision means that FOM cannot carry out activities requiring the coral exemption until the government has properly reassessed the application and issued a new decision.

The minister has been given four months from the date the judgment is sent to reconsider the application, based on new and comprehensive environmental research.

Environmental Studies Covered a Smaller Area Than the Actual Project

The dispute concerns the second phase of an expansion of a luxury resort that FOM has operated in Curaçao since 2009.

The proposed development involves reclaiming approximately 2,800 square meters of land along Curaçao's southern coastline to accommodate additional hotel units.

According to the court, the project consists of approximately 2,000 square meters of land above the waterline and another 800 square meters of underwater slopes forming part of the reclamation structure.

However, the environmental assessments commissioned for the project were based on a smaller development footprint of only 2,000 square meters.

This discrepancy proved decisive.

The court found that researchers had failed to properly account for the additional 800 square meters of underwater structures, creating uncertainty about whether protected coral colonies identified in surrounding waters were actually located within the proposed construction area.

The incomplete assessment also raised questions about whether the proposed buffer zone would provide adequate protection against damage and disturbance.

Protected Coral Species May Have Been Overlooked

Central to the case is the possible presence of coral species protected under Annex II of the Specially Protected Areas and Wildlife (SPAW) Protocol, an international agreement under the Cartagena Convention.

These species benefit from strict legal protection, meaning that activities affecting them may require additional authorization beyond the exemption normally issued under Curaçao's Reef Management Ordinance.

The government maintained that the protected coral colonies previously identified within the project area had died.

However, the plaintiffs submitted underwater photographs taken during diving expeditions in June and September 2026.

The photographs were examined by Carmabi researcher Professor M.J.A. Vermeij, who concluded that they showed coral species protected under the SPAW Protocol.

The court did not establish conclusively that protected corals were present within the construction footprint. Instead, it found that the evidence raised sufficient doubts about the completeness and reliability of the government's environmental investigations.

The judges also noted inconsistencies between different surveys, including protected coral colonies identified during later inspections that had not appeared in earlier research.

These findings demonstrated that protected species could have been overlooked.

Independent Research Recommended

The court ordered the government to commission new research covering the complete development footprint and surrounding buffer zone.

The investigation must be conducted by qualified experts using a reliable and transparent methodology.

Importantly, the court also raised concerns about the independence of environmental consultants involved in the project.

It noted that Corales de Paz, which prepared environmental studies for FOM, was also involved in the proposed long-term coral relocation and restoration program.

Because the consultancy could have an interest in the project's continuation, the court recommended that the government consider appointing another independent expert or arranging an independent review of the findings.

Resort Expansion Cannot Proceed Under Invalidated Exemption

The court emphasized that its ruling does not automatically prohibit the resort expansion permanently.

However, the government must first establish whether internationally protected coral species are present and determine which legal protections and environmental safeguards apply.

If such species are found within the construction area, additional legal requirements under the SPAW Protocol and Curaçao's nature protection legislation must be considered.

The court also ordered the minister to pay XCG 1,400 in legal costs and reimburse court fees of XCG 150 to each of the two groups of plaintiffs.

The parties may appeal the judgment to the Joint Court of Justice within six weeks of the judgment being sent.

For now, the ruling represents a significant setback for the resort expansion and reinforces the requirement that environmental permits be supported by complete and reliable scientific evidence before activities affecting protected marine ecosystems can be authorized.

+