• Curaçao Chronicle
  • (599-9) 523-4857

Analysis: Justice Delayed in Curaçao — How Long Must Citizens Wait for Their Rights?

Local, | By Correspondent November 17, 2026

 

Justice is not measured solely by the outcome of a court case. It is also measured by how long citizens and businesses must wait before a dispute is finally resolved. A person may eventually win a legal battle after years of litigation, but by then, the financial damage, emotional strain, and uncertainty may have already taken their toll.

For Curaçao, this raises a fundamental question: Do we actually know how long it takes for citizens and businesses to obtain a final judicial decision?

And perhaps more importantly, do we know how long taxpayers must wait when they challenge decisions made by their own government?

A Dutch scientific study published in 2020 provides an important starting point for examining these questions. Although the research focused on commercial litigation in the Netherlands, its findings raise broader concerns about the relationship between judicial efficiency, access to justice, and public confidence in the legal system.

What the Dutch Research Revealed

The study, titled De berechting binnen een redelijke termijn – Een empirisch onderzoek naar doorlooptijden in handelszaken (Adjudication Within a Reasonable Time – An Empirical Study of Case Processing Times in Commercial Litigation), was conducted by Remme Verkerk, Frans van Dijk, and Dewy Pistora and published in the Dutch legal journal Tijdschrift voor Civiele Rechtspleging.

The researchers examined more than 100 commercial cases involving financial claims between €1 million and €5 million that had proceeded to appeal.

The findings were revealing.

On average, the recorded proceedings lasted 692 days at first instance and another 774 days on appeal. Together, these stages amounted to approximately four years.

However, the researchers discovered that the officially recorded duration did not necessarily reflect the actual time experienced by the parties involved.

When intermediate periods and separately registered proceedings were included, the total duration reached at least five years and four months. Some disputes lasted considerably longer.

The distinction is crucial.

A court may record the time required to process an individual case, but citizens experience the entire period between the beginning of their dispute and its final resolution.

Administrative statistics and the reality of waiting for justice are not always the same.

The Missing Information in Curaçao

The Dutch findings cannot simply be applied to Curaçao. The two jurisdictions have different caseloads, resources, procedures, and institutional circumstances.

Nevertheless, the study demonstrates why examining the actual duration of legal proceedings is essential.

How long does an ordinary civil case take in Curaçao?

How long does an appeal add to the process?

How many cases remain unresolved after two, four, or six years?

And how often does a dispute move between administrative procedures and different judicial stages before a final decision is reached?

Without comprehensive, publicly accessible statistics covering the entire life cycle of legal disputes, it is difficult to answer these questions with confidence.

This does not necessarily mean that the courts are operating inefficiently. It means that the public needs reliable information to evaluate how effectively the justice system functions.

Transparency about processing times would allow policymakers, legal professionals, businesses, and citizens to identify where delays occur and whether improvements are necessary.

Tax Disputes Deserve Particular Attention

One area where delays can have especially serious consequences is tax litigation.

Unlike an ordinary commercial dispute between two private parties, a tax case places the citizen or business directly opposite the government.

A taxpayer who disagrees with an assessment may first have to pursue an objection before the tax authorities. If the dispute remains unresolved, the matter may proceed through judicial review and potentially appeal.

Each stage takes time.

Meanwhile, the disputed assessment may continue to create financial uncertainty. Depending on the applicable rules and circumstances, collection measures or other financial consequences may also become relevant while the dispute remains unresolved.

For a large corporation, prolonged litigation may represent an expensive administrative burden.

For a small business, however, a disputed tax assessment can affect cash flow, investment decisions, access to financing, and even the ability to continue operating.

For an individual taxpayer, the consequences may be equally serious.

Consider a hypothetical small business owner who challenges a substantial tax assessment. If the dispute takes five years to resolve, the owner may eventually obtain a favorable judgment. Yet during those five years, the uncertainty may have influenced business decisions, financing arrangements, and personal finances.

A favorable ruling cannot automatically restore lost opportunities.

This is why the duration of tax proceedings should be regarded not merely as an administrative issue, but also as a matter of economic security and public trust.

The Right to Justice Within a Reasonable Time

Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights protects the right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time in proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations or criminal charges.

This protection does not establish one universal deadline for every case.

Whether proceedings have taken too long depends on several factors, including the complexity of the dispute, the conduct of the parties, the actions of the authorities, and what is at stake for the individuals involved.

An important legal distinction must be made regarding taxation.

Ordinary disputes over tax assessments generally fall outside the civil-rights protection of Article 6. However, certain tax-related penalties may fall within its criminal-law protection, and other legal safeguards against unreasonable delays may apply to tax proceedings.

Consequently, the absence of direct protection under Article 6 in an ordinary tax assessment dispute does not mean that taxpayers should be expected to tolerate unlimited delays.

A properly functioning legal system must provide meaningful opportunities to challenge government decisions and obtain a resolution within a reasonable period.

The practical question for Curaçao is whether the existing procedures consistently achieve that objective.

Delays Can Undermine Confidence in Government

Lengthy litigation has consequences that extend beyond the courtroom.

When citizens believe that obtaining justice requires years of uncertainty and substantial legal expenses, their willingness to challenge questionable decisions may decline.

Some may abandon legitimate claims because they cannot afford the process.

Others may accept unfavorable settlements simply to end a dispute.

Businesses may become reluctant to invest when legal uncertainty cannot be resolved within a predictable period.

The government itself also has an interest in timely decisions. Prolonged disputes consume administrative resources, complicate financial planning, and can leave important questions about public policy unresolved.

In tax cases, delays can be particularly damaging to the relationship between citizens and the authorities.

A tax system depends not only on enforcement but also on public confidence that assessments are fair, objections are taken seriously, and disagreements can be resolved through an accessible and effective process.

When that confidence weakens, the consequences can extend to voluntary compliance and the perceived legitimacy of government institutions.

Where Do the Delays Actually Occur?

Before drawing conclusions about the performance of Curaçao's legal system, it is necessary to determine where delays arise.

Some may occur before a case ever reaches a courtroom.

Others may result from the complexity of proceedings, requests for additional evidence, procedural decisions, the conduct of litigants, or limited institutional capacity.

In tax disputes, the objection phase deserves particular examination because it may significantly influence the total time required to reach a final outcome.

A meaningful assessment should therefore measure the entire process rather than examining court proceedings in isolation.

For example, a case that spends two years in an administrative objection procedure and another three years before the courts represents five years of uncertainty for the taxpayer, even if the judiciary records only three years.

This distinction was one of the most important lessons of the Dutch research.

If Curaçao measures only individual stages, it risks overlooking the full burden experienced by citizens and businesses.

Time for an Independent Study in Curaçao

The Dutch findings provide a compelling reason to consider an independent investigation into the actual duration of legal proceedings in Curaçao.

The Joint Court of Justice, potentially in cooperation with the University of Curaçao and independent researchers, could explore the feasibility of a comprehensive study covering civil, administrative, and tax disputes.

Such research should examine how long cases take from their initial filing or administrative objection until a final decision is reached.

It should also identify the proportion of cases exceeding two, four, and six years, distinguish between different types of proceedings, and investigate the factors contributing to delays.

Where appropriate, the study could examine the financial and practical consequences for the parties involved.

The purpose should not be to assign blame in advance.

Judges, court personnel, government departments, attorneys, and litigants all operate within procedures that may influence the duration of a case.

An independent study would provide an objective basis for identifying bottlenecks, improving procedures, and determining whether additional resources or legislative changes are necessary.

It could also establish benchmarks against which future improvements could be measured.

Transparency Is the First Step Toward Improvement

A justice system cannot be evaluated effectively without reliable information about its performance.

Publishing comprehensive statistics on case duration would not interfere with judicial independence. On the contrary, greater transparency could strengthen public understanding of the challenges faced by the courts and other institutions involved in dispute resolution.

It would also help distinguish between problems that require administrative improvements and those that demand broader policy or legislative intervention.

Curaçao does not need to assume that its legal system suffers from the same delays identified in the Netherlands.

But neither should it assume that the absence of comprehensive public data means there is no problem.

The appropriate response is to measure, investigate, and make the findings available for public discussion.

Justice Must Be More Than a Final Judgment

Ultimately, the question is not simply whether a citizen can win a case against another party or the government.

The question is whether that citizen can obtain a meaningful resolution before the passage of time makes the victory considerably less valuable.

A legal right that takes years to enforce may offer less practical protection than the law originally intended.

For businesses, delayed justice can mean postponed investment, financial uncertainty, and lost opportunities.

For individuals, it can mean prolonged stress, mounting expenses, and declining confidence in public institutions.

And for the government, it can mean unresolved disputes that undermine trust in the fairness and effectiveness of the system.

The 2020 Dutch research offers Curaçao an important lesson: the duration recorded by a court does not always reflect the time citizens actually spend waiting for justice.

That is why Curaçao should seriously consider independently examining the complete duration of its civil, administrative, and tax proceedings.

A constitutional democracy is not judged only by the rights it grants its citizens. It is also judged by whether those citizens can exercise and enforce those rights within a reasonable time.

Justice delivered eventually may still be justice. But justice delivered too late can lose much of its meaning.

+