THE HAGUE - Scholars are not satisfied with the Dutch plan on how to resolve disputes with the islands from now on. On Wednesday they will talk to Members of the Second Chamber of the Dutch Parliament.

Hassle about organizing elections? Finances in poor order? From The Hague politicians can directly intervene in the administration of the islands. Even as Aruba, Curaçao and St Maarten find that "Dutch ministers" abuse that possibility.

It leads to political arguments. The big wish of the islands is that a kind of judge will be established who can independently make a decision. But Undersecretary Raymond Knops (Kingdom Relations) does not like that.

Scholars' opinions are destructive

Knops has therefore submitted a different bill than was agreed, scholars conclude. For that reason, the dispute settlement procedure could make little sense.

According to Knops' proposal, the Council of State may only issue an advice later. That advice can be set aside if a majority in the Council of Ministers of the Kingdom believes that there are "compelling reasons".

Around 16 Dutch ministers can vote against three representatives from Aruba, Curaçao and St Maarten. That is how the Netherlands can continue to push through its political will, the islands fear.

The aim of a dispute settlement was precisely to find solutions in a peaceful manner, the scholars write.